Tested by Taylor Murray
The call of the New York City bagel draws hungry visitors from all over the nation. For those of us out of PTO or unable to swing a ticket, the grocery store alternatives do little to feed a fierce craving. Luckily, Just Bagels can ship NYC bagels directly to your house. These bagels are baked and shipped fresh to your door, ready to be sliced, schmeared and served. With such lofty promises, I wondered if Just Bagels could truly deliver a bite of New York authenticity, or if I'd just end up with another round piece of bogus bread. I ordered a few cases to find out.
What Are Just Bagels NYC Bagels?
Just Bagels was founded in the Bronx in the early '90s, and their mission is simple: to deliver New York-style bagels to the world. These bagels are made the traditional way, which is hand-crafted, kettle-boiled and baked in a traditional hearth oven. The company's lineup includes all the classics (plain, sesame, everything, blueberry) alongside inventive flavors like marble rye, French toast and chocolate strawberry. They supply grocery stores and cafes nationwide, but their direct-to-consumer boxes mean anyone from Des Moines to Dallas can wake up to the smell of a real New York bagel without ever stepping on a subway.